How to fix a falling apart Cake

Joined
Sep 25, 2014
Messages
542
Reaction score
128
Sometimes, I'm just in too much of a hurry and I don't allow the cake to cool thoroughly enough before attempting to frost it and put the layers together. Other times, the cake is simply too moist and falls apart. Yes, I said too moist. Not a common problem, right? It has happened when I used mayo in place of eggs and oil for baking cakes.

I usually just try to patch it together as best I can, using the icing like "paste." I just wonder if there are any other ideas. I mean, the first idea would be to do it right, so it doesn't fall apart, haha, but when/if it does happen, what do you do? Any tips?
 
Joined
Jul 17, 2013
Messages
1,772
Reaction score
373
When I just started baking I remember losing an entire cake like that :( Not cool! I never had a cake that was too moist tho, but I've had a cake falling apart for being too dry! When that happens it's so hard to put the thing together, specially if you want a layer cake. But yes, the icing has been a savior most of the time. Can't think of any other way to fix a cake that is falling apart tho... I can imagine how messy a cake that is too moist can be tho.
 
Joined
Mar 24, 2015
Messages
209
Reaction score
29
I have had it happen as well. I just used the cake filling to paste it back together. This worked really well because I was using a semi-solid chocolate cream which when warm spread easily, when cool set solid and help the cake together, so that wasn't a problem. It cut up pretty well as well iirc.

The only other option is to bale to something like Nutella (chocolate spread) and warm it slightly. Again it acts as a 'polyfiller' to hold the cake together, but is best with a chocolate flavoured bake - won't work with a fruit cake for which I have no ideas at all!
 
Joined
Jul 12, 2014
Messages
189
Reaction score
29
Usually when that happens, I give myself a few minutes of swearing time and be upset at myself for not being patient enough to wait or for screwing up, but then I just turn around and make them into cake balls :p I don't know if you want to do that but if not, I suppose putting a light layer of frosting on it to cover up the imperfections or to make the cake stick together should work.
 
Joined
Mar 27, 2015
Messages
65
Reaction score
25
Here in the South a popular thing is "Cake Balls." You simply crumble up a cake (perfect use for the falling apart cake) and mix it with the iceing. Then you form it into balls, put on sticks and serve. They look like lolllipops. You can dip them in melted chocolate,,, white, milk or semisweet,, and roll them in nuts, sprinkles, coconut, ect to make them more festive. Personally, I do not care for them because they are so sweet tasting but many people love them. And kids think they are the bomb!
 
Joined
Sep 25, 2014
Messages
542
Reaction score
128
Ah, why didn't I think of cake balls? That would work perfectly. Thanks for the tip, Tangela and Joyce. I'll have to remember that for next time. Well, hopefully I won't have too many next times, but just in case. ;)
 
Joined
Feb 4, 2015
Messages
205
Reaction score
21
If a cake has been sitting out and it's falling apart, you could also freeze it and unfreeze it. This can either make it more brittle and it'll fall to pieces, or it will stick together due to the frozen nature of the cake. This works better with custard or filled cakes, and not just fluffy frosted ones ( if those fall apart, I suggest the cake balls too ). Just a Tim Hortons TimBit or a Donut Hole from anywhere else, it'll satisfy.
 
Joined
Oct 31, 2014
Messages
1,150
Reaction score
264
Sometimes, I'm just in too much of a hurry and I don't allow the cake to cool thoroughly enough before attempting to frost it and put the layers together. Other times, the cake is simply too moist and falls apart. Yes, I said too moist. Not a common problem, right? It has happened when I used mayo in place of eggs and oil for baking cakes.

I usually just try to patch it together as best I can, using the icing like "paste." I just wonder if there are any other ideas. I mean, the first idea would be to do it right, so it doesn't fall apart, haha, but when/if it does happen, what do you do? Any tips?

Now who's the comedian here?:):):) I am going with YOUR first idea:):):). On a serious note though, I would not have a problem if my cake was too moist. I'd make a ball of it and eat until I am about to burst and call it a day. I am soooo surprise that it's even the recommended thing: the "balls" that is.. well maybe I should not be surprise. Perhaps I am feeling a little sad thinking I came here with this great idea when it's already out there.:(
 
Joined
Jul 28, 2017
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Sometimes, I'm just in too much of a hurry and I don't allow the cake to cool thoroughly enough before attempting to frost it and put the layers together. Other times, the cake is simply too moist and falls apart. Yes, I said too moist. Not a common problem, right? It has happened when I used mayo in place of eggs and oil for baking cakes.

I usually just try to patch it together as best I can, using the icing like "paste." I just wonder if there are any other ideas. I mean, the first idea would be to do it right, so it doesn't fall apart, haha, but when/if it does happen, what do you do? Any tips?

I have this problem all the time due to my very moist chocolate cake. After much trial and error i have found something that works. Once it is baked i let it cool in the freezer for about 2 hours. After it has cooled i dirty ice it with a very soft buttercream, i usually add milk to my regular buttercream to soften it to just thicker then a runny ganache. The cake being close to freezing and the buttercream being very spreadable should prevent stress on the cake. This usually stops my cakes from falling apart. Hope this helps.
 
Joined
Sep 8, 2019
Messages
24
Reaction score
9
Natalie Durpree's suggestion, when a cake failed on one of her TV shows, was to dump 'the mess' in a large bowl and give everyone a spoon.
 
Joined
Jan 18, 2022
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
I have this problem all the time due to my very moist chocolate cake. After much trial and error i have found something that works. Once it is baked i let it cool in the freezer for about 2 hours. After it has cooled i dirty ice it with a very soft buttercream, i usually add milk to my regular buttercream to soften it to just thicker then a runny ganache. The cake being close to freezing and the buttercream being very spreadable should prevent stress on the cake. This usually stops my cakes from falling apart. Hope this helps.

Thank you so much!
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
6,542
Messages
47,235
Members
5,496
Latest member
Jack Sr

Latest Threads

Top