New recipe seeking feedback.

Joined
Nov 2, 2026
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
A while now I have been working on a doughnut recipe and I wanted a soft chewy yeast dough for it and this is what I've come up with.

Bread flour 454g
water @ 80 f 299g
buttermilk powder 25g
shortening 40g
sugar 45g
instant yeast 21g
salt 8g
(opt) daistatic malt 2.3g
(opt) mace 1.36g

Procedure is normal with one modification I add the shortening the last 4 minutes of mixing.
 
It sounds like this is a recipe you have developed. If so, I would also look around online for other proven/successful doughnut recipes and compare the ratios of various key ingredients. (Ratios are more effective in doing comparison since the amount each recipe makes could be different.) I find that a good way to not only compare different recipes, but also spot ingredient ratios that vary significantly. Also good to have the instructions for how to combine the ingredients, how long to proof, any special notes, frying temperature/time, etc.
 
It sounds like this is a recipe you have developed. If so, I would also look around online for other proven/successful doughnut recipes and compare the ratios of various key ingredients. (Ratios are more effective in doing comparison since the amount each recipe makes could be different.) I find that a good way to not only compare different recipes, but also spot ingredient ratios that vary significantly. Also good to have the instructions for how to combine the ingredients, how long to proof, any special notes, frying temperature/time, etc.
I used the ABA recommendations, as well as the recipe of Wayne Gisslen as a baseline. He wrote text text book i learned from in school so I figured it was a good place to start.
 
Mixing time 8 to 10 minutes, first proof until doubled, and the final by feel usually about 20 to 30 minutes before frying. I used the modified straight dough method without the creaming stage. Just all dry into the mixer then liquids and mix watching for the dough to become cohesive and pull away from the sides.
 
One thing that caught my attention is the instant yeast quantity. 21g for 454g of bread flour seems quite high, especially if you're aiming for a longer fermentation and better flavour development. Have you experimented with reducing it slightly to see how it affects the dough's texture and flavour?

I also like the idea of adding the shortening during the final few minutes of mixing. It should help with gluten development before the fat is incorporated. I'm curious how the finished doughnuts turn out – are you getting the soft, chewy texture you're aiming for while still keeping a light interior?
 
One thing that caught my attention is the instant yeast quantity. 21g for 454g of bread flour seems quite high, especially if you're aiming for a longer fermentation and better flavour development. Have you experimented with reducing it slightly to see how it affects the dough's texture and flavour?

I also like the idea of adding the shortening during the final few minutes of mixing. It should help with gluten development before the fat is incorporated. I'm curious how the finished doughnuts turn out – are you getting the soft, chewy texture you're aiming for while still keeping a light interior?
the original recipe called for 1.5 oz with 1 pound 13 oz bread flour. I did reduce it by a third already and considered dropping it further.
 

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
6,843
Messages
49,222
Members
5,774
Latest member
C Squared

Latest Threads

Back
Top