Sourdough starter v instant yeast

Joined
Mar 25, 2022
Messages
103
Reaction score
7
Can I use sourdough starter in place of my 7grams of instant yeast for my tinned loaf and if so how much?
 
Randomly swapping/adding ingredients in a bread recipe is usually a bad idea, whether sourdough starter, water or other ingredients. Will be far better use of your time to find a proven/tested recipe from a pro chef that has the key ingredients you have in mind. Probably will waste of a lot of time/money experimenting with variations on your own. Sourdough starter reacts differently than yeast with the other ingredients.
 
Thank you that's all I wanted to know - sourdough starter reacts differently then yeast.
 
When somebody tells me not to do something or that I am wrong I expect them to tell me why otherwise I learn nothing from the exchange!
 
When somebody tells me not to do something or that I am wrong I expect them to tell me why otherwise I learn nothing from the exchange!
Yeh, in a class where you pay.
Ask yourself, if I keep making the same mistake with everything, what am I not learning.
 
I agree but so long as you know what the mistake is! If you don't know what the mistake is you just continue to be ignorant!
 
I think the main difference is that instant yeast is a concentrated, predictable leavening agent, while sourdough starter contains both wild yeast and lactic acid bacteria. This means it behaves differently, produces acidity and develops flavour over a longer fermentation period.

Also, a starter contains flour and water, so replacing 7g of instant yeast isn't simply a matter of swapping it gram for gram. You would need to adjust the flour and hydration in the recipe as well. That's why starting with a tested sourdough loaf recipe is usually the better approach. It's interesting how much the fermentation method can change the final bread texture and flavour!
 

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
6,843
Messages
49,222
Members
5,774
Latest member
C Squared

Latest Threads

Back
Top