Shortbread Cookies - blobbing out


Joined
Dec 8, 2019
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
My Canadian aunt gave me a recipe which she uses to make her own cookies.

BC - Canada
1&1/2 cups Self Raising flour
1/2 cup Cornflour
1 cup Salted butter (add more to make dough bind)
1/4 cup Sugar (or more to your taste)

UK
330g Self Raising Flour
200g Salted Butter (KerryGold)
100g Sugar (tried Granulated or Caster)

I've tried and tried adjusting measures into UK 'grams' but cannot stop the mix blobbing out on the tray during bakng.

I soften the butter 'KerryGold' and mix into the sugar, then into the flour by hand. Have tried to keep the mix to barely binding together.
Roll out to 3/8" '10mm' thick, then punch out the cookies using either a egg cup or a shot measure glass.
These are placed on a thin baking tray covered with parchment paper. (Have tried baking directly from rolling or chilling in the fridge for 30mins.)
The electric oven pre-heated to 180 baked 20/25mins till lightly browned
During the baking they all blob out joining others aside.

So where/what I am doing wrong....

thank you
 
Last edited:
Ad

Advertisements

Joined
Jun 23, 2017
Messages
2,369
Reaction score
1,232
My Canadian aunt gave me a recipe which she uses to make her own cookies.

BC - Canada
1&1/2 cups Self Raising flour
1/2 cup Cornflour
1 cup Salted butter (add more to make dough bind)
1/4 cup Sugar (or more to your taste)

UK
330g Self Raising Flour
200g Salted Butter (KerryGold)
100g Sugar (tried Granulated or Caster)

I've tried and tried adjusting measures into UK 'grams' but cannot stop the mix blobbing out on the tray during bakng.

I soften the butter 'KerryGold' and mix into the sugar, then into the flour by hand. Have tried to keep the mix to barely binding together.
Roll out to 3/8" '10mm' thick, then punch out the cookies using either a egg cup or a shot measure glass.
These are placed on a thin baking tray covered with parchment paper. (Have tried baking directly from rolling or chilling in the fridge for 30mins.)
The electric oven pre-heated to 180 baked 20/25mins till lightly browned
During the baking they all blob out joining others aside.

So where/what I am doing wrong....

thank you
1. plain flour not self rising flour. Shortbread should NOT be leavened.

2. Mix dough. Roll into a smooth rectangle. Cover with plastic wrap.

3. Chill dough at least 4 hrs up to 24 hrs.


you can use up to 80% butter. The UK recipe only has 60% butter in it.

I baked 3 dozen shortbread cookies today. I use jazz some Kerrygold, some Plugra (an American brand). my recipe has 80% butter in it.


AB1629AE-69C2-4D76-A2FF-685613730931.jpeg


227A2D52-150D-41C6-8BBC-0DB15623FCB2.jpeg
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top